There was a famous bagel shop by my old school
Salmon cream cheese with white fish and fresh cucumber
Oh, it was my favorite thing (favorite thing)
A cinnamon bagel with spicy lentil soup
What a strange combination, but I would get the same one
Cause it was your favorite thing (favorite thing)
Oh, you were cool as a cucumber
Even in the hot summer in New York
It was a piece of cake to fall in love with you
By the autumn in New York
it was my favorite thing
That’s the way the cookie crumbles, you used to tell me
You were a smart cookie, and I had a very sweet tooth
In this big ripe apple, or more like a pickle jar
I finally found you, the sweetest apple of my eye
Oh, you were my everything (everything, Everything Bagel)
Oh you were cool as a cucumber
Even in the hot summer in New York
It was a piece of cake to fall in love with you
By the autumn in New York
You were my favorite thing
You were my favorite thing (everything, Everything Bagel)
Everything